Lose It vs MyFitnessPal comes down to how you like to count. Lose It is built around one number, a daily calorie budget, and is the simpler app to live with; MyFitnessPal gives more on its free plan, including macro goals, and has the bigger ecosystem of linked apps and languages. Both charge $79.99 a year for Premium in the US, both show ads on the free plan, and in 2026 neither gives every free user a barcode scanner. Pick Lose It if you want plain calorie counting for weight loss; pick MyFitnessPal if you care about protein and macros or want the widest app support.
This guide compares the two on free features, barcode scanning, food databases, macros, logging shortcuts, price, ads and devices, then gives clear rules for who should pick which.
We make FitArchive, so weigh our view accordingly. We did not install or hands-on test either app: everything below is compared from each app’s official pricing pages, help centre and store listings. Prices and limits were checked on the vendors’ own pages on 20 November 2026; they change by country.
Lose It vs MyFitnessPal at a glance
| Lose It! | MyFitnessPal | |
|---|---|---|
| Built around | A personalised daily calorie budget | A food diary with calorie and macro goals |
| Free plan | Calorie budget, food database, weight-loss plan, community | Food and exercise logging, custom foods and recipes, macro view, calorie and macro goals by percentage |
| Ads on the free plan | Yes | Yes |
| Barcode scanner | Moving to Premium during 2026; some free members keep it for now | Premium only since 1 October 2022 |
| Photo logging | Premium (photo and voice) | Premium (Meal Scan) |
| Food database claim | 50M+ foods (help centre); 56M+ items and recipes (App Store) | 20.5M+ foods, including restaurant dishes |
| Premium price (US) | $79.99 a year; Lifetime $299.99 | $19.99 a month or $79.99 a year |
| Free trial | 7 days for new Premium users | 7 days if you never had Premium |
| Remove ads without Premium | Yes, a one-time “Eliminate Ads” purchase | No |
| Data export | Not found on the pages we read | Premium only |
| Apple Watch | Yes | Yes |
| Wear OS | Not found | Yes (English only) |
| App Store languages | 9 | About twice as many |
| Adaptive calorie targets | Not found on vendor pages | Not found on vendor pages |
Sources: Lose It! membership and pricing, Lose It! barcode change, Lose It! on the App Store, MyFitnessPal’s Free vs Premium comparison, MyFitnessPal barcode help and MyFitnessPal on the App Store.
Is Lose It better than MyFitnessPal?
Neither is better for everyone. They solve slightly different problems.
Lose It is better if your goal is weight loss and you want to think in one number. The free plan gives you a personalised daily calorie budget and access to the full food database. You log, you see how much of the budget is left, and that is most of the job.
MyFitnessPal is better if you want more control for free. Its free plan includes viewing macros and setting calorie and macro goals by percentage, plus custom foods, meals and recipes, diary sharing and links to partner apps. It is also on more platforms and in more languages.
Most people who switch between the two do so over one of three things: the barcode scanner, ads, or how many taps a normal day takes. The sections below go through each.
What you get for free
Lose It Basic costs $0 and, in Lose It’s own words, includes “essential tracking tools, including a personalized daily calorie budget and access to our 50M+ food database.” The App Store listing adds the weight-loss plan and community to the free list. Custom goals for nutrients, water and sleep are on the Premium list, so treat detailed macro goals as a paid feature.
MyFitnessPal Free covers food and exercise logging, body measurements and progress, custom foods, meals and recipes, viewing macros, calorie and macro goals by percentage, diary sharing, partner-app links and a printable report on the website, according to its Free vs Premium comparison.
The practical difference: on MyFitnessPal’s free plan you can set a protein share, say 30% of calories, and see how close you are. Setting protein in grams needs Premium (“macros by gram”). On Lose It, plan on Premium if you want custom nutrient targets at all.
Barcode scanning in 2026
This is where most older comparisons are now wrong.
- MyFitnessPal: “As of October 1, 2022, Barcode Scan is available only with a Premium subscription.” That has not changed since.
- Lose It: a help article updated on 1 April 2026 says Lose It is “in the process of moving the barcode scanner (Scan It) and nutrition label scanner” to Premium, and that “some free members will still have access as we transition.” Scan It also requires your device language to be English.
So if a free barcode scanner is the reason you are choosing, neither app is a safe bet. If you have one now on Lose It’s free plan, expect it may move behind Premium. Free apps that still scan barcodes, such as Cronometer, are covered in our MyFitnessPal alternatives guide and the Cronometer vs MyFitnessPal comparison.
Food database: size is not the same as accuracy
Lose It’s help centre claims a “50M+ food database”, and its App Store text says “56+ million items and recipes”. MyFitnessPal’s App Store text says “20.5M+ foods, including restaurant dishes”. On paper, Lose It’s number is more than twice as big.
Treat both numbers with care:
- They are counted differently. “Items and recipes” and “foods” are not the same unit, and neither vendor says how duplicates are handled.
- Neither publishes a verified share. We found no figure on either vendor’s pages for how many entries are checked by staff rather than added by users.
- What matters is the first result. When you search “chicken breast” or scan a yoghurt, you want the right entry near the top. A database ten times bigger does not help if the top three results disagree by 100 calories.
A simple habit fixes most database problems in either app: for foods you eat often, check one entry against the package label or a reference source once, save it as a favourite or custom food, and reuse it. After a week, most of your diary comes from that short list.

Macros and protein: which is better for lifters?
If you lift and care about protein, MyFitnessPal’s free plan does more. You can see macros and set macro goals by percentage at no cost. Premium adds macros by gram, quick-add macros, different goals on different days and goals per meal, which suits people who eat more on training days.
Lose It treats macros as a secondary layer on top of the calorie budget, and custom nutrient goals are listed as Premium.
What either app cannot tell you is whether your training is working. For a cut, the numbers that matter most are protein and whether your lifts hold. Our guide to keeping muscle while cutting covers protein, rate of loss and how to read your log, and how much protein per day gives the ranges the research supports. If you are not sure whether to cut at all, read body recomposition vs bulking and cutting.
Logging speed and shortcuts
We did not time either app, so we will not claim one is faster. What the vendor pages do show is which shortcuts are free and which are paid:
| Shortcut | Lose It! | MyFitnessPal |
|---|---|---|
| Search the database | Free | Free |
| Custom foods, meals, recipes | Tier not stated on the pricing page | Free |
| Barcode scan | Moving to Premium | Premium |
| Photo logging | Premium | Premium (Meal Scan) |
| Voice logging | Premium | Offered; tier not stated in the sources we read |
| Log future meals or several days | Premium (future meal logging) | Premium (multi-day logging) |
| Quick-add macros | Not found | Premium |
The pattern is the same in both: the free plan is fast once you have saved your regular meals, and slow when every day is new food. If you eat a lot of packaged food and the scanner is gone, expect more typing on either free plan.
Price: is Lose It Premium worth it?
MyFitnessPal Premium lists $19.99 a month or $79.99 a year on the US App Store, with a 7-day free trial only if you have never had Premium or a Premium trial. Premium+ adds a meal plan builder, meal prep mode and grocery lists; the App Store list does not label its price separately. Over a year, monthly billing costs $239.88. Annual billing costs less if you expect to subscribe for at least five months; four monthly payments total $79.96, just below the $79.99 annual price.
Lose It Premium is “$79.99 USD / Year” on its pricing page, with a 7-day free trial for new users. Lifetime is $299.99 for free accounts and $229.99 for active Premium members. Lose It also says it “adjusts prices based on various factors like seasonal promotions and how often you use the app”, and the App Store lists several lower Premium price points, so you may be offered less than $79.99.
A simple rule for whether Lose It Premium is worth it:
- Worth it if you rely on the barcode or label scanner, want photo or voice logging, need custom nutrient goals, or want your smartwatch or tracker to sync.
- Not worth it if you only search foods and watch the calorie budget. That part is free.
- Lifetime at $299.99 equals about 3.75 years of the $79.99 yearly price ($229.99 is about 2.9 years). It only pays off if you are sure you will still be counting in four years.
The same logic applies to MyFitnessPal Premium: pay for the specific feature you miss (usually the scanner, gram-level macros or export), not for the list.
Ads
Both free plans show ads. MyFitnessPal says plainly: “The core of MyFitnessPal is free, and it stays that way because ads help pay for it.” Google Play labels Lose It “Contains ads”.
The difference is how you remove them. On MyFitnessPal, ad-free comes with Premium. Lose It’s help centre describes a separate one-time “Eliminate Ads” purchase that removes full-page and Log banner ads without buying Premium; upgrade prompts and some affiliate cards remain. If ads are your only complaint, check the one-time Eliminate Ads price in the app before choosing Premium.
Devices, languages and your data
- Platforms. Both run on iPhone, Android and the web, and both have an Apple Watch app. MyFitnessPal also has a Wear OS companion app, which it says is “only available in English”. We found no Lose It Wear OS app on its vendor pages.
- Languages. Lose It lists 9 languages on the App Store (including French, German, Japanese, Portuguese and Spanish). MyFitnessPal lists about twice as many, including Indonesian, Italian, Russian and Turkish. Neither lists Vietnamese; if you eat Vietnamese food, see our Vietnamese calorie counter guide.
- Device sync. MyFitnessPal links to partner apps on the free plan. Lose It lists smartwatch and tracker sync as Premium.
- Export. MyFitnessPal says “Free accounts don’t include a data export tool”; export is Premium. We did not find Lose It’s export terms on the pages we read, so check before you commit years of data.
- GLP-1. Both apps now market GLP-1 medication features. If you are on one, protein and resistance training matter for keeping lean mass; our GLP-1 research update summarises recent studies.
Neither vendor page describes adaptive calorie targets that adjust from your actual weight trend. You set a goal, and you change it yourself when progress stalls. If that matters to you, read MacroFactor vs MyFitnessPal, which explains how adaptive targets work.
MyFitnessPal vs Lose It: who should pick which
Pick Lose It if:
- You want to lose weight and think in one daily number.
- You prefer a simpler app with fewer settings.
- Ads bother you but you do not want a subscription (the one-time ad removal).
- You might buy once and keep it for years (Lifetime).
Pick MyFitnessPal if:
- You track protein or macros and want goals on the free plan.
- You use an app or device that links to it, or you wear a Wear OS watch.
- You need a language Lose It does not offer.
- You want Premium+ meal planning and grocery lists.
Pick neither if a free barcode scanner, no ads, or deep micronutrients matter most. The MyFitnessPal alternatives guide linked above lists apps that do those for free.
Switching between them. MyFitnessPal export needs Premium, so if you are leaving, export before you cancel. An export file does not establish import compatibility: we did not verify a direct history-transfer route between these apps. Keep the original account or export, and rebuild your 20 to 30 most common foods as favourites in the new app during the first week.
If you also lift: food and workouts in FitArchive
Both are food-first apps. MyFitnessPal’s Premium Workout Routines also log individual exercise sets; we found no RIR field in the reviewed sources. FitArchive is a third option for people who lift: one app for workouts and food, with no ads and no account needed to start. On the free plan you log every set with weight, reps and reps in reserve, see your last session beside each set, search 360,000+ foods with calories and macros (none user-submitted; about 10,000 are available offline, and the larger catalogue uses online search), and scan barcodes for free on iPhone, Android and the web.
Be aware of the trade-offs: FitArchive tracks only fiber, sodium and sugar beyond macros, has no community, and its packaged-food coverage outside the US may be thinner than crowd-sourced apps. AI photo meal logging and adaptive calorie and macro targets are part of Plus ($2.99 a month or $19.99 a year in the US), not free, and paid AI features require iPhone or Android and sign-in.
See pricing and how it compares, try the web demo, or get it for iPhone or Android.
FAQ
Is Lose It better than MyFitnessPal for weight loss? Lose It is simpler for weight loss because everything centres on a daily calorie budget. MyFitnessPal can do the same job and gives more macro control for free. Weight loss depends on the calorie deficit you keep, not the app, so choose the one you will open every day.
Is MyFitnessPal still free? Yes. Logging food and exercise, custom foods and recipes, and calorie and macro goals by percentage are free, with ads. The barcode scanner, Meal Scan, gram-level macros, export and ad-free use need Premium.
Is barcode scanning free on Lose It? Not for everyone any more. Lose It is moving its barcode and nutrition label scanners to Premium in 2026, and says some free members keep access during the transition. The scanner also needs your device language set to English.
How much is Lose It Premium? Lose It’s pricing page lists $79.99 a year in the US, with Lifetime at $299.99 (or $229.99 for active Premium members). Lose It says prices vary with promotions and app usage, so you may see a lower offer.
Does Lose It have more foods than MyFitnessPal? By its own count, yes: 50M+ foods (56M+ items and recipes on the App Store) against MyFitnessPal’s 20.5M+. The units differ and neither publishes how many entries are verified, so the bigger number does not guarantee better results for your foods.
Can I use both Lose It and MyFitnessPal? You can, but logging the same food twice doubles the work and most people stop. Run a one-week trial of each, then keep the one you actually used every day.
Lose It! and MyFitnessPal are trademarks of their respective owners. FitArchive is not affiliated with or endorsed by either.
